Distinguishing Between Borderline PD & Depression

DISCLAIMER

The content provided in this Substack post is for entertainment and informational purposes only and is not intended to serve as medical advice. The views and opinions expressed herein are those of the writer and should not be taken as definitive or authoritative. Readers should not rely solely on the information provided in this post to make decisions about patient care. Instead, use this content as a starting point for further research and consult a qualified healthcare professional before making any changes to treatment or medication regimens.

---

Introduction:

The world of psychiatric diagnosis can sometimes feel like a labyrinth, with many conditions sharing overlapping symptoms. This makes distinguishing between them challenging but crucial, as accurate diagnosis guides the treatment pathway. Two conditions that often lead to diagnostic confusion are Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) and Major Depressive Disorder (MDD). This post will delve into the nuances of each and provide helpful tips for distinguishing them. But first we will review a relevant patient scenario, as you read the passage, consider the following questions:

1. What is your initial diagnosis?

2. What additional information would you seek to confirm your diagnosis?

3. Given your tentative diagnosis, how would you approach a treatment plan?

4. What possible challenges might you anticipate in managing this patient?

Patient Scenario:

Patient Presentation:

Laura, a 26-year-old woman, enters your clinic with a self-referral. She looks tired, her shoulders hunched and her gaze avoiding direct eye contact. She describes feeling persistently low and "empty" for the past several months. Most days, she struggles to get out of bed or even carry out simple tasks like cooking or cleaning. This persistent sadness has interrupted her sleep pattern, alternating between phases of insomnia and hypersomnia.

She also talks about her inability to sustain any enjoyment or interest in activities she used to love like painting and hiking. There are frequent bouts of uncontrolled weeping, sometimes even in public, and she feels a constant sense of overwhelming guilt and worthlessness.

Upon delving deeper into her past, Laura confesses she had experienced similar episodes, some even more severe where she contemplated suicide. A sense of foreboding dread seems to hang over her story as she shares these details, pointing towards a chronic and cyclic pattern of these depressive episodes.

While her self-stated symptoms seem to indicate a depressive disorder, Laura's conversation paints a broader picture. She repeatedly brings up her current relationship, voicing excessive worry that her partner will abandon her. She talks about past relationships, marked by an intense and turbulent pattern, frequently bouncing between idealization and devaluation of her partners.

Laura admits to making impulsive decisions in moments of stress, like overspending on online shopping or binge-eating late at night. These impulsive episodes often exacerbate her feelings of guilt and worthlessness. Laura reports a chronic feeling of emptiness and emotional instability, describing her emotions as being on a roller coaster ride.

As her story unravels, it's clear that Laura is dealing with more than just depression. Her life seems filled with persistent instability, not just in mood but also in relationships and self-image.

Diagnosis and Treatment Plan:

Based on the provided information, the initial diagnosis for Laura would be Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD). While she does present with symptoms that align with a depressive disorder, these can also be seen as part of the emotional dysregulation often associated with BPD.

Laura's chronic feelings of emptiness, her history of volatile relationships, fear of abandonment, and impulsive and potentially self-damaging behaviors, particularly when under stress, align more distinctly with BPD. These symptoms tend to be pervasive and consistent, and their presence would require a reevaluation of Laura's self-diagnosis of depression.

To confirm the diagnosis, one would need additional information. This might include asking Laura about any self-harming behaviors or recurrent suicidal thoughts, behaviors that are often associated with BPD. Additionally, one would explore her early family environment and relationships as childhood neglect or trauma can contribute to the development of BPD.

The treatment plan would largely focus on psychotherapy, with Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) being the therapy of choice. DBT is a type of cognitive-behavioral therapy that equips individuals with new skills to manage painful emotions and decrease relationship conflicts. It's particularly effective in reducing self-harm behaviors and improving relationships for individuals with BPD.

Depending on Laura's needs, medication may also be considered to manage individual symptoms like mood swings or impulsivity. However, these should not be the primary treatment method as no medication has been approved by the FDA for treating BPD, and their effectiveness can vary widely among individuals.

The management of a patient with BPD can be complex and challenging, particularly due to their intense emotional responses and fear of abandonment. This fear can manifest in various ways in a therapeutic relationship and might lead to fluctuations in Laura's engagement with therapy. Regular, supportive follow-ups, a strong therapeutic alliance, and a comprehensive risk management plan are essential in such cases.

Additionally, it's crucial to remember that Laura's self-perception and interpretation of relationships may be skewed, leading to situations that she perceives as deeply distressing while appearing less severe to others. These instances should be handled with patience and understanding, ensuring that Laura feels seen and heard throughout her therapeutic journey.

---

Next we will review both diagnoses & consider the distinct differences to keep an eye on when treating patients.